Manny Ramirez is a free agent. Manny Ramirez is still a free agent. Let me repeat that again, for good measure: Manny Ramirez is a FREE AGENT. What the hell is going on here? Barry Bonds would blame it on collusion but no one is accusing Manny of using the “cream” or the “clear.” A quick run-down of the situation shows that teams are afraid of “Manny being Manny,” becoming unhappy and, according to the higher-ups, a “clubhouse distraction.” That phrase causes GMs to fall out of their chairs, managers to quake, and players to…well, keep playing. Honestly, the idiom might as well be “bullshit” because that’s what a clubhouse distraction is: bullshit. You know how Manny was creating all kinds of trouble for the Red Sox last year? Trouble to the tune of a .918 OPS in 100 games for the Sauuuux. Sure, that was a bit under his career numbers in Boston but still, few players in the majors had higher OPS’s last year. In the entire American League there were four players who finished the season with a higher number in that category than Ramirez, and if you look at what Manny did in Los Angeles, the man would have finished in first in the AL. In fact, he has third-highest OPS in the majors last year, behind only Albert “I OBP at .500” Pujols and my boy Chipper Jones. Of course, he isn’t credited with finishing first in the NL for what he did in Chavez Ravine because he spent too little time there but damn, he had a godly 1.232 OPS there in 53 games.
So what’s the story morning glory? Why are teams refusing to sign this man who could honestly go down as one of the ten greatest hitters of all time? Apparently, Manny will cause you trouble. Which makes a whole of sense considering how baseball is such a game of chemistry…or not. It’s pitcher vs. batter, not O-Line vs. D-Line. Honestly, team chemistry is a bunch of bunk when you’re talking about baseball. The pitcher and the catcher don’t even have to like each other as long as the catcher can call a good game from behind the plate. Baseball is unique among team sports because it doesn’t require so much “chemistry” among teammates – in football, timing is a huge part of things and developing a rapport with your receivers as a quarterback is vital; in basketball, a point guard needs to have a feel for the tendencies of his teammate, who can jump out of the building, to master his alley-oop pass; in soccer, the quick one-two’s placement and timing is built on knowing your teammates. Baseball, however, has few opportunities for this to be important. About the only one is the double play, but the most celebrated combination ever (rightly or wrongly as research shows it was overrated), Tinkers to Evers to Chance, wasn’t exactly the model of cordiality. The Cubs’ Joe Tinker, shortstop, and Johnny Evers, second baseman (the most important parts of the typical double play-combos 6-4-3 and 4-6-3) had ongoing feuds that strained their relations. Despite this terrible development in their team chemistry, they still managed to turn double plays.
There are many examples to demonstrate how the concepts “clubhouse distraction” and “team chemistry” are crap when you’re talking about baseball. I mean, it can’t hurt to like your teammates, but really, how many Giants really liked Barry Bonds when San Francisco was good back in the early 2000s? He was a recluse from the rest of the players even though he was a massive media distraction, even before steroids. Alex Rodriguez has been a constant source of attention, mostly negative, in New York, and the man is still the best (or second-best…it’s him or Pujols) hitter in the league (and not a choker in big situations, you fuckin’ idiots who perpetuate that myth). Another Yankee in the past was a major media-suck: Reggie Jackson. Mr. October and Steinbrenner, along with team captain Thurman Munson, weren’t exactly all buddy-buddy, but hey, Jackson was such an utter annoyance and disturbance that the Yankees won the World Series that year in his first season in pinstripes. Gosh darn-it all, you clubhouse distractions! We can’t win with you here!
Now that the truth about chemistry in baseball has been exposed, what does this mean for Manny? Well, it means any team with a GM who has half-a-brain should try to sign him. Naturally, with the current economic problems there aren’t that many who can afford to dole out a four year, $90 to $100 million contract. But there are some who can, like the Dodgers, who for some absurdly stupid reason are balking at the idea of keeping Manny and his more than 1.200 OPS around for a few more seasons. The Nationals are looking to spend some dough with their new ballpark improving team revenues and really should try to get him if no one else will. Even the Yankees, who I abhor for their reckless spending this off-season, ought to throw him some bones if they are willing. Really, it is just ridiculous that the man is still unsigned less than a month before spring training. Some numbers: 37 HRs/130 RBIs/.344 BA/.482 OBP/.634 SLG/1.116 OPS vs. 41 HRs/133 RBIs/.314 BA/.411 OBP/.593 SLG/1.004 OPS. These are 162-game averages for two different players. The second set of numbers is Manny Ramirez. The first is the greatest player in Red Sox history, Ted Williams. Now, Teddy Ballgame had a better eye than Manny, as seen by his absurd OBP but the other numbers aren’t too far apart. So yes, Manny Ramirez is frickin’ good. Despite his 36 years of age, the man can still hit and would especially be a good signing by an AL team that can stick him in the designated-hitter slot if his fielding, already the source for some amusing Sportscenter highlights, gets a lot worse.
Hopefully, some non-Steve Phillips-like GM who uses these things called statistics to evaluate players and not moronic standards like “he plays hard so he must be good” will sign the man to hit some baseballs. However, knowing the utter stupidity of many baseball GMs, a number of which can afford to sign a player of Manny’s cost and caliber, Ramirez will likely remain unsigned. Someone should just let Manny be Manny – it’ll probably get whatever team is smart enough to sign him a lot more runs and, thus, a lot more wins.
Thanks Geoff, well done. More posts coming soon, we promise.